Monday, 5 March 2012

Tips for Transgender Breastfeeders and Their Lactation Educators

I've been in touch recently with several lactation consultants and they have all asked me similar questions: What is it like to breastfeed as a transgender man? Are there special challenges that you face? What do we need to learn in order to help people like you to breastfeed?

So here's a post for anyone out there who may one day be in a position to help a trans guy and his nursling in their journey towards achieving a kick-ass breastfeeding relationship, because it CAN happen.

Tip One: Simply know that it is possible for a trans guy to breastfeed even after a dramatic chest surgery like mine. A lot of people thought I was ridiculous and delusional for trying to breastfeed, but I did it. My son gets a little bit of my very own milk plus the milk of lots of wonderful women via a supplemental nursing system (SNS - see FAQ). All feedings take place at the breast.

Tip Two: Know that latching will likely be particularly tough. Lactation advisers should know that trans men may face special challenges in latching their babies - accomplishing a deep latch can be very difficult with next to zero breast tissue. Teaching a trans man to make an effective "breast tissue sandwich" is essential to successful and reasonably comfortable breastfeeding. Using an SNS on top of this makes breastfeeding even harder. A first time trans breastfeeder will need lots of extra hands to help with latching and using the SNS.

 Tip Three: Lactation consultants should be aware that in the case of a trans guy who has not had any chest surgery, he may have practiced years of breast binding to flatten his chest, and this, of course, may affect milk production.

Breast binder on a model
Many FtM individuals practice breast binding, using very tight fitting garments to flatten the chest. As we know, even an ill-fitting bra can affect milk production.


Tip Four: Watch out for postpartum depression (PPD), even more than usual. Emotional factors surrounding breastfeeding should be given serious consideration by any lactation adviser. A trans man may be very averse to breastfeeding if he perceives the practice to be a feminine activity (I for some reason never felt this way myself), or depending on his own feelings about his chest and nipples. Alternately, even though he is happy he had his surgery, he may still feel very guilty if he is unable to make enough milk for his baby. Watching out for PPD could be very important since trans people as a group are already at higher risk of suicide and depression than the general population.

Tip Five: Act as a liaison between your client and others, such as La Leche League. Remember all those women you urged to contact La Leche League but they never did? Think they were anxious about going to a meeting full of strangers? Well, now imagine being a trans guy walking into a room of breastfeeding women who know nothing about you. How daunting would this be? To help a trans client find peer-to-peer breastfeeding support, locate a queer-friendly LLL chapter or similar group and let them know ahead of time that a trans breastfeeder may be joining them. Then tell your client that the group leader is familiar with the notion of a breastfeeding trans man and will be welcoming.

Finally, be prepared to learn, innovate, and improvise. Have fun!

9 comments:

  1. I just found and caught up on your blog. I have to say I am very impressed. As the partner of a MtF transsexual I have a lot of empathy for your situation. I can only imagine how difficult it is for you when you must nurse in public and some ignorant person confronts you.

    My partner has provided me back up with our own children and those who know of her trans-status have been very concerned at the possibility of her producing 'something unknown' that my children intake. It is upsetting to me to hear the comments of 'what comes from a man may be different' or 'what may the hormones be doing' and she only really comfort nurses our kids when I cannot be around. I can only imagine being in your position, stay strong and know you have support even if it isn't always obvious.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Wow, what an amazing gift you and your partner are able to give your kids. I'm sure tons of people wish they could comfort their babies more easily while the primary nursing parent is away! Lucky kids.

      I've had tons of comments about "the hormones I'm taking" and how they must affect the baby (both during the pregnancy and now). I kindly inform such people that I stopped taking the hormones in order to become pregnant, and that the endocrinologist told me that testosterone clears the system in about ten days. So, I haven't had synthetic testosterone in my body for about two years now. I guess it is hard for people to understand because my voice has remained low and my facial hair continues to grow.

      Delete
    2. I realize it's a bit late, but for future reference- There have been studies done on the content of galactorrhea (medicine refuses to call it "lactation" because they don't want to consider that cis men could breastfeed) from cis men that found it was comparable to what cis women produce when breastfeeding. And that was without taking any estrogen/progesterone to develop the breast tissue- which could only make the breast tissue more comparable to cis women, not less. Kulski, Hartmann, and Gutteridge did one study on this in 1981 and mention an earlier study that studied different aspects of galactorrhea that found the same thing.

      It can help to have scientific research to back you up against the "well meaning" concerns people can have, especially if you ever face difficulties from doctors.

      Delete
  2. Great advice, thank you very much. I will finish my training as an LC one day, and I hope I get a chance to use your tips.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks for reading! Good luck in your LC training - what a satisfying career that will be to assist parents in nurturing their babes.

      Delete
  3. I work with breastfeeding moms ( I think I need to change that to "breastfeeding parents"!) and I was thrilled to read this post! While I have worked with lesbian couples (one where both mothers wanted to breastfeed, and another where the mom carrying the baby did not want to breastfeed, and there other mother did), I had not thought about the situation you describe. With all that I know about breastfeeding, including outside of the "norm" (I'm currently breastfeeding an adopted baby), I would have thought that it would not be possible for someone in your situation. I'm so excited to read about your success.
    I'm looking forward to reading more of your blog posts. Thank you for sharing.
    This is me: http://thebreastfeedingmother.blogspot.com/

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hello Trevor,

    This is a wonderful post!! Thanks so much for taking the time to write it. I would love to quote it in an article I’m writing, and would like to get your permission to do so. Please contact me at snd74@me.com, and I would be happy to explain in greater detail.

    Thank you very much.
    Sara

    ReplyDelete
  5. I would hope the LLLI leaders and lactation consultants would be supportive...

    LLLI was probably aboutthe first place I felt comfortable feeding my baby outside of the house...

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi Trevor,

    This is fantastic!

    I am preparing a workshop on this topic and would love to use your suggestions. Most of this information is in the presentation, but I would love to use your tips 1-5! Please contact me by email so that we can discuss: jschockemoehl@gmail.com.

    ReplyDelete