31 Jul 2012

Public Health, Economics and Breastfeeding Goals

This morning I noticed that at the top of The New York Times' "most-emailed" articles list was yet another post about the hardships of breastfeeding and the bullies in the medical establishment who continue to berate us with the message, "breast is best." This particular one was entitled, "The Ideal and the Real of Breastfeeding," by Jane E. Brody. It closely mirrored the feminist arguments of Elisabeth Badinter's recently published book, The Conflict: How Modern Motherhood Undermines the Status of Women. These authors and their followers commonly suggest that doctors, nurses and public health officials should stop making breastfeeding seem like such an important factor in infant health so as to avoid inducing motherly guilt. It seems not to occur to any of them that perhaps what Americans need instead is a set of laws, government programs, and business practices that support babies and their families.

Telling us that breastfeeding isn't important because in some cases it's rather difficult to accomplish is like saying that, since they are having trouble doing it, our school-aged kids don't actually need to eat more vegetables and fewer fatty foods even though they are suffering from poor health. After all, we wouldn't want to hurt their feelings, would we? No, in this situation, I believe parents generally agree that schools should make an effort to remove nutritionally abysmal food and drink such as French fries and pop from cafeterias. We need to help our children develop healthy eating habits and we know that surrounding them with excellent choices will go a long way toward making this happen.

Why, then, do writers such as Jane Brody insist that we change our stated societal breastfeeding goals instead of doing better to support breastfeeding parents? In part, they argue that breastfeeding isn't really as beneficial for babies as parents are made to believe. After all, Brody says, "No randomized, controlled trials – the gold standard of scientific research – have proved that breast-fed babies fare better, at least in industrialized countries." This is in fact because such a study would be impossible to perform. No parent would agree to breastfeed or formula feed randomly as decided by a scientist. Even if they did, some in the group assigned to breastfeed would fail to do so since not everyone who wants to breastfeed succeeds.

Nevertheless, it's easy to find solid evidence that shows breastfeeding is good for infant health, and, not surprisingly, good for business. Breastfeeding support programs instituted by employers result in 62% fewer prescriptions as well as substantial health care savings and reduced absenteeism, according to the insurance company CIGNA. Companies with lactation support programs also enjoy much higher rates of employee retention than the national average. Of course, insurance companies exist to make money – if they are convinced that breastfeeding saves health care dollars, I'm inclined to believe them.

Another large part of Badinter's argument against breastfeeding concerns the time and energy that it takes on the part of the mother. As a breastfeeding dad, I have certainly experienced firsthand this kind of commitment. However, it has little to do with breastfeeding and everything to do with the fact that human babies are extraordinarily needy, dependent creatures who prefer a consistent caregiver. Infants cannot feed themselves, take care of their elimination needs, protect themselves, or move any real distance on their own. If I don't look after my baby, some other adult must do it for me regardless of whether he's slurping breast milk or formula. Rather than bemoaning what I have "given up" to take care of my baby, I try to consider his needs as an infant. After all, he didn't choose to be here; we brought him into this world. Fortunately for me, being Canadian, I was entitled to one year of parental leave with employment insurance that paid a decent chunk of my previous income.

I wish that these authors would demand longer paid parental leaves. The current US standard six week leave is laughable – it is hardly enough time to get to know and support a new family member. Most of my friends have said they didn't get into the groove of breastfeeding (or parenting!) until at least six months in. To meet the minimum breastfeeding goals outlined by public health officials, Americans need much longer parental leaves as well as workplace lactation support programs for those who choose to go back to work. Let's change our attitudes and programs to support family health rather than redefining good health to mean good enough.


  1. I think all too often the push to "have it all" at the expense of an infant defeats feminism rather than bolstering it. Embracing "the family" as many other countries already have only stregnthens the workforce because it encourages those that are mothering to return to the workforce rather forcing them to pick raising a child or working.

  2. Walmart was actually very accommodating of me pumping at work.sitting down to pump was as restful enough.
    People are looking for validation of their excuses, and authors like that one provide them.

  3. You are doing a great job. Now we are sharing with you all the Tresurebox store products which you will be buy online in a single click. Garden shed nz online in a single click,

  4. Watch your latest pinoy tv channel replays online in a single click. ofw pinoy channel provide you all the replays which you will be get online in hd. pinoy tv daily share with you latest replays online.

  5. Pinoy Tambayan is Filipino teleserye channel to watch all ofw pinoy tv replays

  6. Watch and download Korean drama, movies, Kshow and other Asian dramas with english subtitles online free. Dramacool for everyone!

    KissAnime was an anime-focused file streaming website that hosted links and embedded videos, allowing users to stream or download movies and TV shows ...

  7. After all the country slogan is it's more fun in the Philippines. You can take our word that the Philippines has the happiest and friendliest people in the world pinoy tv pinoy tv pinoy tv

  8. Pinoy Channele bringing you best videos from all over Filipino entertainment, sports,
    news, politics, technology, music, covering all Latest Tv Replay Show of Pinoy Teleserye.

    Nagbabagang Luha

  9. Bade Achhe Lagte Hain 2 is a upcoming Hindi Indian soap opera that will
    premiere on 30 August 2021 at 8:00 P.M. in Sony Entertainment Television.

    Yeh Rishta Kya Kehlata Hai

  10. From MX Player original hindi shows to Hindi dubbed shows you can make your
    weekend full of entertainment with these top 10 hindi web series streaming

  11. After reading your article, I am once again convinced of the need to insure the child's life. We haven't done the eldest daughter yet, but I think it's worth it. I am currently reading united healthcare reviews, I think what can be done there. Tell me who made life insurance where, because I think that it is really very important. And I wonder if it is possible to make insurance for an infant.


  12. Mehndi Hai Rachne Wali is Star Plus & Hotstar started newly launched Drama Serial
    Raghav puts necklace on Kirti, Kirti thanks Pallavi, Pallavi says thank Raghav

    Zindagi Mere Ghar Aana

  13. Zindagi Mere Ghar Aana (Star Plus) Cast and Crew, Roles, Release Date, Trailer.
    Zindagi Mere Ghar Aana is a Star-Plus tv show. This tv show was produced by.

    Saath Nibhaana Saathiya 2

  14. Today's episode starts with Kanta getting emotional. Anuj asks Kanta
    what happened. Devika asks Kanta if she said anything wrong. Anupama asks

    Anupama Today

  15. Vivian D'Sena, who was last seen on the show Shakti - Astitva Ke Ehsaas Ki,

  16. Star Star Plus Hindi Desi Serials Watch Online Hotstar Official Video. Latest Updates Enjoy full episodes Yeh Rishta Kya Kehalta Hai live.

    Kundali Bhagya

  17. KissAsian is the best website to Korean dramas and movies online free with
    English Subtitles and Dubbed. This website Chris Gayle, movies of genres ...

  18. Health is very important and especially important for young children because they are at risk for many diseases. My son is only 4 years old but he already has some problems with the correct growth of his teeth and we go to the pediatric dentist. You can see more reviews at https://clear-choice.pissedconsumer.com/review.html and see what other people who treat their teeth have to say. I have already visited their dentistry before and my doctor did everything well and advised me how to brush my teeth properly.


  19. DramaCool is korean tv kshow123 website which provides latest
    Korean drama, movies, Kshow and kissasian dramas with english
    subtitles online free in hd quality. DramaCool for everyone!