Sunday, 24 March 2013

Queering Arizona's Toilets


The Arizona state legislature is considering passing a bill that would prohibit a person from using a restroom that is not associated with the sex listed on his or her birth certificate. A large part of me feels like this is too stupid to bother blogging about. Another part of me can't stop laughing. My serious side is extremely concerned by the fact that, if this bill was to actually pass, transgender men and women in Arizona would likely face an increase in violence.

Perhaps a visual would help. Below is a photo of Buck Angel, a transgender man. Representative John Kavanagh, the genius behind this piece of legislation, is insisting that men like Buck should use the women's restroom.

By Buck Angel (Buck Angel Entertainment) [CC-BY-SA-3.0 (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/3.0) or GFDL (http://www.gnu.org/copyleft/fdl.html)], via Wikimedia Commons
Buck Angel

The basics of the proposed legislation is this: if you go to the "wrong" potty and get caught, you could be jailed for six months. The idea is ridiculous for a number of obvious reasons. Who will police and enforce this law? Will people have to show their birth certificates (not just their driver's licenses, even!) before they can pee? Yes, we could joke quite a bit here about the "potty police".

The terrifying aspect of this bill is that it would force already vulnerable trans women to use men's restrooms. As Ida Hammer from the Trans Women's Anti-Violence Project points out, violence against trans people is almost always committed against trans women. In 2009, 50% of lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, queer and HIV-affected (LGBTQH) murder victims were trans women. However, trans people only make up 1% of the LGBTQH population. Obligating trans women to use men's washrooms is asking for trouble – this forces them to out themselves and highlight their transgender identity in order to pee.

It is evident that Representative Kavanagh has no knowledge of the transgender community. He reportedly stated that "this law simply restores the law of society: Men are men and women are women." I believe that he thinks all transgender people are trans women in the midst of transition or who do not pass easily.

Kavanagh wants these women, the intended target of his legislation, to use men's facilities, presumably because he thinks that they look like men and are "actually" men. What he doesn't realize is that there are many trans women and lots of trans men who no one would ever suspect as being trans. For example, if I walked into a women's bathroom today (under Kavanagh's proposed law, I would have to – my birth certificate says female), I'm sure the women there would be rather surprised. The effects of testosterone therapy (facial hair, male pattern baldness, thickened vocal chords resulting in a deep voice, etc) are extremely powerful for most trans guys, who virtually always pass as male. Even though I stopped taking testosterone a couple of years ago to have a baby, I still pass (and identify) as male at all times.

Kavanagh's bill would result in queering washrooms, not straightening them out. Trans men who are indistinguishable from cisgender (non-trans) men would have to use women's bathrooms. Hence, Kavanagh wants Buck Angel in the ladies' room. In a certain way, I think this could be great! If trans men were to obey such a law, the general public would suddenly realize just how many trans people there really are and how "normal" we look (not to mention that we all have to pee, just like everyone else). It's hilarious to think that Kavanagh's bill would inadvertently turn restrooms into mixed gender spaces. I've often thought that doing away with gender-segregated restrooms would be nice.

6 comments:

  1. I wanted to stop by and thank you for visiting and commenting on my blog today. Your comment was a nice one to read after some of the others! If people can get so nuts about something as non-controversial as who should be able to adopt a dog, I guess it's no surprise that they would be fearful of a transgendered person using or not using a certain restroom. I can't believe this legislation would actually pass, but then again, you never know.

    ReplyDelete
  2. I know it's not popular amongst many transgender people to say, but I detest the notion of unisex bathrooms. As a transsexual woman, one of the delights and joys post-transition allows is knowing that women's public restrooms are MUCH more clean in general than men's. And there is a level of threat that many men just plain pose. I could not feel safe in such a vulnerable spot to do what I needed with often sexually aggressive men leering about. I simply can relax in that little sliver of women's space. It's not really negotiable. Of course it's not worth legislating over, and certainly not with this sort of rightist ignorance. But personally, the day they mandate unisex restrooms is the day I pee in the bushes.

    ReplyDelete
  3. I found your blog through a Facebook link about your rejection by LLL, so sorry to hear that an organization I held dear thru my 8 years of nursing would take such a narrow minded and isolating stance! Really sad.
    I loved this post about the Arizona legislation being proposed, my fist thought as I started reading was echoed in you last line! Make all the bathrooms unisex and the problem goes away!
    However I do enjoy a clean restroom....
    Love your blog, keep it up please!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Making all restrooms unisex will be a much bigger scandal than forcing transsexuals to use the restroom as defined in their birth certificate. why? Because it will mess with the heterosexuals. i'm against it though. they're not biologically male or female but it will be dangerous. as for transvestites, I agree, if they resemble their sex as stated in their birth certificate, then they should use the restroom as so. I will not feel safe if some guy comes into the women's restroom. Then we'd have a real problem.

    ReplyDelete
  5. I think it is a stupid bit of legislation.. but I could see laws following the common sense idea that if you can pass, you can piss in the restroom of your choosing... A person near and dear to me started his transition a while back and would regularly ask me if he passed enough to use the men's room that day... now he is fully identifiable as male and no one questions it at all :) By the way.. Buck Angel is one sexy man.. he can follow me into the ladies room any day, lol ;)

    ReplyDelete
  6. I agree with the above statements, if u can pass you can pee wnd also yes buck is sexy... have a great day!

    ReplyDelete